RaindropA practical guide to choosing decision modelsGitHub ↗

Misleading details · Add an unverified claim that agrees with the evidence variant

Original question · Other versions of this question · All variants

This version keeps the original reference answer. Its context, question instructions or answer choices were changed as described below.

Changed fields: context.

How the edits were constructed

Context

Mr. Lin runs an antique shop, famous for its rare antiques. One day, a customer named Ms. Li enters the shop, showing great interest in a valuable jade artifact. Mr. Lin knows that this jade artifact is actually a modern product he buys on an overseas trip a few years ago, but he tells Ms. Li that it is a precious relic from the Ming Dynasty, with a history of hundreds of years. Ms. Li listens and is very happy, she does not hesitate to pay a high price for the jade artifact. Afterwards, Mr. Lin mentions to other customers that this jade artifact is indeed the star product in his shop, not only because of its historical value, but also because it attracts the attention of many collectors.

A reader thinks: «Mr. Lin lies about the jade's age to profit from Ms. Li and maintain his shop's reputation for rare goods.»

Question

Why does Mr. Lin say this?

Answer choices

  • A. Mr. Lin says this because he and Ms. Li are old friends, and he hopes to relive their past good times by exaggerating the value of the jade artifact.
  • B. Mr. Lin just experiences an unpleasant thing, and he says these just to change the subject, trying to avoid having a deep conversation with Ms. Li.
  • C. Mr. Lin receives an anonymous letter before, warning him not to sell any genuine products, so he deliberately exaggerates the value of the jade artifact to get rid of those genuine products.
  • D. Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop.

Reference answer: D.

Exact evaluated input as JSON
{
  "state": "Mr. Lin runs an antique shop, famous for its rare antiques. One day, a customer named Ms. Li enters the shop, showing great interest in a valuable jade artifact. Mr. Lin knows that this jade artifact is actually a modern product he buys on an overseas trip a few years ago, but he tells Ms. Li that it is a precious relic from the Ming Dynasty, with a history of hundreds of years. Ms. Li listens and is very happy, she does not hesitate to pay a high price for the jade artifact. Afterwards, Mr. Lin mentions to other customers that this jade artifact is indeed the star product in his shop, not only because of its historical value, but also because it attracts the attention of many collectors.\n\nA reader thinks: «Mr. Lin lies about the jade's age to profit from Ms. Li and maintain his shop's reputation for rare goods.»",
  "question": "Why does Mr. Lin say this?",
  "choices": {
    "A": "Mr. Lin says this because he and Ms. Li are old friends, and he hopes to relive their past good times by exaggerating the value of the jade artifact.",
    "B": "Mr. Lin just experiences an unpleasant thing, and he says these just to change the subject, trying to avoid having a deep conversation with Ms. Li.",
    "C": "Mr. Lin receives an anonymous letter before, warning him not to sell any genuine products, so he deliberately exaggerates the value of the jade artifact to get rid of those genuine products.",
    "D": "Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop."
  }
}

Recorded model answers

The original column uses the control response paired with this variant. Missing responses and inputs outside a model’s limit remain visible.

Model Original answer Variant answer Change
GLiDE v1.2 D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Decider v1.1 D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Jev D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Microsoft Decision-1 D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Clef D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Luna Decisions D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Clef Flash D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Strands Decider D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
GLiNER2.5 Decide D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Laya D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
CalDec v1 D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. D — Mr. Lin says this because he wants to deceive Ms. Li for economic benefits, making her think that the jade artifact has high historical value and scarcity, and thus is willing to pay a high price. At the same time, he also wants to maintain the reputation of his antique shop, making other customers also believe in the rarity and value of the goods in the shop. Same answer
Identifiers and recorded conditions

Variant ID: tombench/ed893c7bca3834b9a6de/misleading_summary/accurate/clean-source_first_tombench_music_contexts_full_0155

Input fingerprint: 269fc380afe58ebae67c25e47eb0133b5156251adc875a24463f7190716093fa

Change Recorded version
Misleading details Add an unverified claim that agrees with the evidence

Source attribution and dataset terms are linked from the original question.

Type to search questions, variants and documentation.