RaindropA practical guide to choosing decision modelsGitHub ↗

Misleading details · Add an unverified claim that agrees with the evidence variant

Original question · Other versions of this question · All variants

This version keeps the original reference answer. Its context, question instructions or answer choices were changed as described below.

Changed fields: context.

How the edits were constructed

Context

Read the full context

{"user_request": "I want to find a movie to watch with Ving Rhames.", "available_tools": [{"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "description": "Search for movies based on specific criteria such as director, genre, and cast.", "parameters": {"type": "dict", "properties": {"directed_by": {"type": "string", "description": "The director of the movie. Use 'dontcare' if the director is not a search criterion.", "default": "dontcare"}, "genre": {"type": "string", "description": "The genre of the movie. Use 'dontcare' if the genre is not a search criterion.", "enum": ["Offbeat", "Fantasy", "World", "Mystery", "Thriller", "Comedy", "Comedy-drama", "Horror", "Animation", "Sci-fi", "Cult", "Drama", "Anime", "Family", "Action", "dontcare"], "default": "dontcare"}, "cast": {"type": "string", "description": "The lead actors in the movie. Use 'dontcare' if the cast is not a search criterion.", "default": "dontcare"}}, "required": []}}, {"name": "Music_3_PlayMedia", "description": "Plays the selected music track on the specified device.", "parameters": {"type": "dict", "required": ["track"], "properties": {"track": {"type": "string", "description": "The title of the song to be played."}, "artist": {"type": "string", "description": "The name of the artist performing the song.", "default": "Any Artist"}, "device": {"type": "string", "description": "The device where the music will be played. Choose from a list of available players.", "enum": ["Living room", "Kitchen", "Patio"], "default": "Living room"}, "album": {"type": "string", "description": "The name of the album that the song belongs to.", "default": "Any Album"}}}}, {"name": "Music_3_LookupMusic", "description": "Discover songs that match your music preferences, such as artist, album, genre, and release year.", "parameters": {"type": "dict", "required": [], "properties": {"artist": {"type": "string", "description": "The name of the performer or band. Use 'dontcare' to ignore this filter.", "default": "dontcare"}, "album": {"type": "string", "description": "The name of the album containing the song. Use 'dontcare' to ignore this filter.", "default": "dontcare"}, "genre": {"type": "string", "description": "The musical style or category of the song. Use 'dontcare' for no preference.", "enum": ["Reggae", "Holiday", "Electropop", "Pop", "Asia", "House", "Electronica", "Funk", "Rock", "Metal", "Dubstep", "Country", "dontcare"], "default": "dontcare"}, "year": {"type": "string", "description": "The year the song was released. Format: 'YYYY'. Use 'dontcare' to ignore this filter.", "enum": ["2010", "2011", "2012", "2013", "2014", "2015", "2016", "2017", "2018", "2019", "dontcare"], "default": "dontcare"}}}}]}

A reader thinks this response is appropriate: «{"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}}».

Question

Which candidate response is most appropriate, given the user's request and the available tools?

Answer choices

  • request_for_info. To help you find a movie, could you please specify the genre you're interested in?
  • tool_call. {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}}
  • direct. Sure, I recommend "Mission: Impossible - Fallout". Ving Rhames plays the character Luther Stickell in this action-packed film. Enjoy!
  • cannot_answer. I'm sorry, I can't provide movie recommendations based on specific actors as I don't have that functionality. You may want to check a movie database for this information.

Reference answer: tool_call.

Exact evaluated input as JSON
{
  "state": "{\"user_request\": \"I want to find a movie to watch with Ving Rhames.\", \"available_tools\": [{\"name\": \"Movies_3_FindMovies\", \"description\": \"Search for movies based on specific criteria such as director, genre, and cast.\", \"parameters\": {\"type\": \"dict\", \"properties\": {\"directed_by\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The director of the movie. Use 'dontcare' if the director is not a search criterion.\", \"default\": \"dontcare\"}, \"genre\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The genre of the movie. Use 'dontcare' if the genre is not a search criterion.\", \"enum\": [\"Offbeat\", \"Fantasy\", \"World\", \"Mystery\", \"Thriller\", \"Comedy\", \"Comedy-drama\", \"Horror\", \"Animation\", \"Sci-fi\", \"Cult\", \"Drama\", \"Anime\", \"Family\", \"Action\", \"dontcare\"], \"default\": \"dontcare\"}, \"cast\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The lead actors in the movie. Use 'dontcare' if the cast is not a search criterion.\", \"default\": \"dontcare\"}}, \"required\": []}}, {\"name\": \"Music_3_PlayMedia\", \"description\": \"Plays the selected music track on the specified device.\", \"parameters\": {\"type\": \"dict\", \"required\": [\"track\"], \"properties\": {\"track\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The title of the song to be played.\"}, \"artist\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The name of the artist performing the song.\", \"default\": \"Any Artist\"}, \"device\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The device where the music will be played. Choose from a list of available players.\", \"enum\": [\"Living room\", \"Kitchen\", \"Patio\"], \"default\": \"Living room\"}, \"album\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The name of the album that the song belongs to.\", \"default\": \"Any Album\"}}}}, {\"name\": \"Music_3_LookupMusic\", \"description\": \"Discover songs that match your music preferences, such as artist, album, genre, and release year.\", \"parameters\": {\"type\": \"dict\", \"required\": [], \"properties\": {\"artist\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The name of the performer or band. Use 'dontcare' to ignore this filter.\", \"default\": \"dontcare\"}, \"album\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The name of the album containing the song. Use 'dontcare' to ignore this filter.\", \"default\": \"dontcare\"}, \"genre\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The musical style or category of the song. Use 'dontcare' for no preference.\", \"enum\": [\"Reggae\", \"Holiday\", \"Electropop\", \"Pop\", \"Asia\", \"House\", \"Electronica\", \"Funk\", \"Rock\", \"Metal\", \"Dubstep\", \"Country\", \"dontcare\"], \"default\": \"dontcare\"}, \"year\": {\"type\": \"string\", \"description\": \"The year the song was released. Format: 'YYYY'. Use 'dontcare' to ignore this filter.\", \"enum\": [\"2010\", \"2011\", \"2012\", \"2013\", \"2014\", \"2015\", \"2016\", \"2017\", \"2018\", \"2019\", \"dontcare\"], \"default\": \"dontcare\"}}}}]}\n\nA reader thinks this response is appropriate: «{\"name\": \"Movies_3_FindMovies\", \"arguments\": {\"cast\": \"Ving Rhames\"}}».",
  "question": "Which candidate response is most appropriate, given the user's request and the available tools?",
  "choices": {
    "request_for_info": "To help you find a movie, could you please specify the genre you're interested in?",
    "tool_call": "{\"name\": \"Movies_3_FindMovies\", \"arguments\": {\"cast\": \"Ving Rhames\"}}",
    "direct": "Sure, I recommend \"Mission: Impossible - Fallout\". Ving Rhames plays the character Luther Stickell in this action-packed film. Enjoy!",
    "cannot_answer": "I'm sorry, I can't provide movie recommendations based on specific actors as I don't have that functionality. You may want to check a movie database for this information."
  }
}

Recorded model answers

The original column uses the control response paired with this variant. Missing responses and inputs outside a model’s limit remain visible.

Model Original answer Variant answer Change
GLiDE v1.2 tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} Same answer
Decider v1.1 tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} Same answer
Jev tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} Same answer
Microsoft Decision-1 tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} Same answer
Clef tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} Same answer
Luna Decisions tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} Same answer
Clef Flash tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} Same answer
Strands Decider tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} tool_call — {"name": "Movies_3_FindMovies", "arguments": {"cast": "Ving Rhames"}} Same answer
GLiNER2.5 Decide cannot_answer — I'm sorry, I can't provide movie recommendations based on specific actors as I don't have that functionality. You may want to check a movie database for this information. cannot_answer — I'm sorry, I can't provide movie recommendations based on specific actors as I don't have that functionality. You may want to check a movie database for this information. Same answer
Laya direct — Sure, I recommend "Mission: Impossible - Fallout". Ving Rhames plays the character Luther Stickell in this action-packed film. Enjoy! direct — Sure, I recommend "Mission: Impossible - Fallout". Ving Rhames plays the character Luther Stickell in this action-packed film. Enjoy! Same answer
CalDec v1 request_for_info — To help you find a movie, could you please specify the genre you're interested in? request_for_info — To help you find a movie, could you please specify the genre you're interested in? Same answer
Identifiers and recorded conditions

Variant ID: when2call/1bf636ebc93cea9b17bf/misleading_summary/accurate/clean-bare_when2call_reader_opinions_full_0069

Input fingerprint: f74a897adfd8157490d921e78b481e5a978dcf16b996ec8680c341d69d75725d

Change Recorded version
Misleading details Add an unverified claim that agrees with the evidence

Source attribution and dataset terms are linked from the original question.

Type to search questions, variants and documentation.