Misleading details · Add an unverified claim that agrees with the evidence variant
Original question · Other versions of this question · All variants
This version keeps the original reference answer. Its context, question instructions or answer choices were changed as described below.
Changed fields: context.
How the edits were constructed
Context
A reader thinks, "If E and G were both true, the premises would require both F and not F; hence the conclusion not G or not E follows and the argument is valid."
Question
Use indirect truth tables to determine whether the following argument is valid. If the argument is invalid, choose an option which presents a counterexample. (There may be other counterexamples as well.) E ⊃ F G ⊃ ~F / ~G ∨ ~E
Answer choices
- A. Valid
- B. Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true
- C. Invalid. Counterexample when E and G are true and F is false
- D. Invalid. Counterexample when F and G are true and E is false
Reference answer: A.
Exact evaluated input as JSON
{
"state": "A reader thinks, \"If E and G were both true, the premises would require both F and not F; hence the conclusion not G or not E follows and the argument is valid.\"",
"question": "Use indirect truth tables to determine whether the following argument is valid. If the argument is invalid, choose an option which presents a counterexample. (There may be other counterexamples as well.)\nE ⊃ F\nG ⊃ ~F / ~G ∨ ~E",
"choices": {
"A": "Valid",
"B": "Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true",
"C": "Invalid. Counterexample when E and G are true and F is false",
"D": "Invalid. Counterexample when F and G are true and E is false"
}
}
Recorded model answers
The original column uses the control response paired with this variant. Missing responses and inputs outside a model’s limit remain visible.
| Model | Original answer | Variant answer | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| GLiDE v1.2 | A — Valid |
A — Valid |
Same answer |
| Decider v1.1 | A — Valid |
A — Valid |
Same answer |
| Jev | A — Valid |
A — Valid |
Same answer |
| Microsoft Decision-1 | A — Valid |
A — Valid |
Same answer |
| Clef | A — Valid |
A — Valid |
Same answer |
| Luna Decisions | A — Valid |
A — Valid |
Same answer |
| Clef Flash | A — Valid |
A — Valid |
Same answer |
| Strands Decider | B — Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true |
A — Valid |
Different answer |
| GLiNER2.5 Decide | A — Valid |
D — Invalid. Counterexample when F and G are true and E is false |
Different answer |
| Laya | A — Valid |
B — Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true |
Different answer |
| CalDec v1 | A — Valid |
B — Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true |
Different answer |
Identifiers and recorded conditions
Variant ID: mmlu/757b7f30fb2d3c8a089a/misleading_summary/accurate/clean-source_first_mmlu_reader_claims_full_0197
Input fingerprint: 70a3a82bd92a3b32aac9b2f645c8aee8ead9b1785e4128e6a108dcd4af35e421
| Change | Recorded version |
|---|---|
| Misleading details | Add an unverified claim that agrees with the evidence |
Source attribution and dataset terms are linked from the original question.