RaindropA practical guide to choosing decision modelsGitHub ↗

Misleading details · Add an unverified claim that agrees with the evidence variant

Original question · Other versions of this question · All variants

This version keeps the original reference answer. Its context, question instructions or answer choices were changed as described below.

Changed fields: context.

How the edits were constructed

Context

A reader thinks, "If E and G were both true, the premises would require both F and not F; hence the conclusion not G or not E follows and the argument is valid."

Question

Use indirect truth tables to determine whether the following argument is valid. If the argument is invalid, choose an option which presents a counterexample. (There may be other counterexamples as well.) E ⊃ F G ⊃ ~F / ~G ∨ ~E

Answer choices

  • A. Valid
  • B. Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true
  • C. Invalid. Counterexample when E and G are true and F is false
  • D. Invalid. Counterexample when F and G are true and E is false

Reference answer: A.

Exact evaluated input as JSON
{
  "state": "A reader thinks, \"If E and G were both true, the premises would require both F and not F; hence the conclusion not G or not E follows and the argument is valid.\"",
  "question": "Use indirect truth tables to determine whether the following argument is valid. If the argument is invalid, choose an option which presents a counterexample. (There may be other counterexamples as well.)\nE ⊃ F\nG ⊃ ~F / ~G ∨ ~E",
  "choices": {
    "A": "Valid",
    "B": "Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true",
    "C": "Invalid. Counterexample when E and G are true and F is false",
    "D": "Invalid. Counterexample when F and G are true and E is false"
  }
}

Recorded model answers

The original column uses the control response paired with this variant. Missing responses and inputs outside a model’s limit remain visible.

Model Original answer Variant answer Change
GLiDE v1.2 A — Valid A — Valid Same answer
Decider v1.1 A — Valid A — Valid Same answer
Jev A — Valid A — Valid Same answer
Microsoft Decision-1 A — Valid A — Valid Same answer
Clef A — Valid A — Valid Same answer
Luna Decisions A — Valid A — Valid Same answer
Clef Flash A — Valid A — Valid Same answer
Strands Decider B — Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true A — Valid Different answer
GLiNER2.5 Decide A — Valid D — Invalid. Counterexample when F and G are true and E is false Different answer
Laya A — Valid B — Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true Different answer
CalDec v1 A — Valid B — Invalid. Counterexample when E, F, and G are true Different answer
Identifiers and recorded conditions

Variant ID: mmlu/757b7f30fb2d3c8a089a/misleading_summary/accurate/clean-source_first_mmlu_reader_claims_full_0197

Input fingerprint: 70a3a82bd92a3b32aac9b2f645c8aee8ead9b1785e4128e6a108dcd4af35e421

Change Recorded version
Misleading details Add an unverified claim that agrees with the evidence

Source attribution and dataset terms are linked from the original question.

Type to search questions, variants and documentation.