Text length · 2,048-token input target variant
Original question · Other versions of this question · All variants
This version keeps the original reference answer. Its context, question instructions or answer choices were changed as described below.
Changed fields: context.
How the edits were constructed
Context
Read the full context
{"pre_text": ["an adverse development with respect to one claim in 2008 and favorable developments in three cases in 2009 .", "other costs were also lower in 2009 compared to 2008 , driven by a decrease in expenses for freight and property damages , employee travel , and utilities .", "in addition , higher bad debt expense in 2008 due to the uncertain impact of the recessionary economy drove a favorable year-over-year comparison .", "conversely , an additional expense of $ 30 million related to a transaction with pacer international , inc .", "and higher property taxes partially offset lower costs in 2009 .", "other costs were higher in 2008 compared to 2007 due to an increase in bad debts , state and local taxes , loss and damage expenses , utility costs , and other miscellaneous expenses totaling $ 122 million .", "conversely , personal injury costs ( including asbestos-related claims ) were $ 8 million lower in 2008 compared to 2007 .", "the reduction reflects improvements in our safety experience and lower estimated costs to resolve claims as indicated in the actuarial studies of our personal injury expense and annual reviews of asbestos-related claims in both 2008 and 2007 .", "the year-over-year comparison also includes the negative impact of adverse development associated with one claim in 2008 .", "in addition , environmental and toxic tort expenses were $ 7 million lower in 2008 compared to 2007 .", "non-operating items millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 % ( % ) change 2009 v 2008 % ( % ) change 2008 v 2007 ."], "table": [["millions of dollars", "2009", "2008", "2007", "% ( % ) change 2009 v 2008", "% ( % ) change 2008 v 2007"], ["other income", "$ 195", "$ 92", "$ 116", "112 % ( % )", "( 21 ) % ( % )"], ["interest expense", "-600 ( 600 )", "-511 ( 511 )", "-482 ( 482 )", "17", "6"], ["income taxes", "-1089 ( 1089 )", "-1318 ( 1318 )", "-1154 ( 1154 )", "-17 ( 17 )", "14"]], "post_text": ["other income 2013 other income increased $ 103 million in 2009 compared to 2008 primarily due to higher gains from real estate sales , which included the $ 116 million pre-tax gain from a land sale to the regional transportation district ( rtd ) in colorado and lower interest expense on our sale of receivables program , resulting from lower interest rates and a lower outstanding balance .", "reduced rental and licensing income and lower returns on cash investments , reflecting lower interest rates , partially offset these increases .", "other income decreased in 2008 compared to 2007 due to lower gains from real estate sales and decreased returns on cash investments reflecting lower interest rates .", "higher rental and licensing income and lower interest expense on our sale of receivables program partially offset the decreases .", "interest expense 2013 interest expense increased in 2009 versus 2008 due primarily to higher weighted- average debt levels .", "in 2009 , the weighted-average debt level was $ 9.6 billion ( including the restructuring of locomotive leases in may of 2009 ) , compared to $ 8.3 billion in 2008 .", "our effective interest rate was 6.3% ( 6.3 % ) in 2009 , compared to 6.1% ( 6.1 % ) in 2008 .", "interest expense increased in 2008 versus 2007 due to a higher weighted-average debt level of $ 8.3 billion , compared to $ 7.3 billion in 2007 .", "a lower effective interest rate of 6.1% ( 6.1 % ) in 2008 , compared to 6.6% ( 6.6 % ) in 2007 , partially offset the effects of the higher weighted-average debt level .", "income taxes 2013 income taxes were lower in 2009 compared to 2008 , driven by lower pre-tax income .", "our effective tax rate for the year was 36.5% ( 36.5 % ) compared to 36.1% ( 36.1 % ) in 2008 .", "income taxes were higher in 2008 compared to 2007 , driven by higher pre-tax income .", "our effective tax rates were 36.1% ( 36.1 % ) and 38.4% ( 38.4 % ) in 2008 and 2007 , respectively .", "the lower effective tax rate in 2008 resulted from several reductions in tax expense related to federal audits and state tax law changes .", "in addition , the effective tax rate in 2007 was increased by illinois legislation that increased deferred tax expense in the third quarter of 2007. ."]}
The conservatory occupies a shallow courtyard between a brick residence and a former workshop. Its glazed roof rests on slender iron ribs, while the lower walls retain the texture of old lime plaster. The entrance faces a sheltered gravel court. Through the door, a broad stone path leads toward a recessed bench beneath the far gable. Planting beds lie beside the path, separated from it by low terracotta edging. The interior feels enclosed without feeling cramped: the roof exposes the sky, and the neighboring walls give the planting a sheltered boundary.
The entrance door has a heavy timber frame and a narrow pane of textured glass. Its handle is polished where hands naturally rest, but the surrounding metal retains a subdued finish. A deep threshold separates the gravel court from the interior paving. Beside the door, a shallow alcove accommodates a brush, a folded cloth, and a rack of garden footwear. The alcove is part of the wall rather than a freestanding cupboard, leaving the entrance passage clear. A slight projection above the doorway shelters the outer face of the timber from direct rain.
The main path consists of broad limestone slabs with softened edges. Their surface has a faint granular texture, and the joints contain a compact lime mortar. Near the planting beds, the paving has a narrow drainage channel with a removable grating. The channel follows the wall instead of crossing the entrance. The bed edging rises only slightly above the path, making the soil visible from the bench. Along the workshop wall, the slabs meet an older strip of brick paving whose uneven surface gives that side of the room a more domestic character.
The roof glazing is held in timber glazing bars laid over the iron frame. At the ridge, small ventilation panels sit beneath projecting caps. The caps shelter the opening edges while leaving a passage for air. The roof has a steeper pitch above the central path and a lower profile where it meets the neighboring walls. Narrow gutters follow the eaves. Their supporting brackets are visible from inside, where they form a quiet rhythm against the uninterrupted glass. The metalwork has a muted finish rather than a reflective coating.
The planting beside the residence wall is dominated by broad leaves and arching stems. Ferns occupy the shaded ground beneath taller foliage, and moss softens the exposed soil around the bed edges. The leaves differ in texture: some are smooth and leathery, others finely divided, with delicate veins visible against the roof light. None of the beds is raised on a stand. The plants emerge directly from a continuous soil surface, which gives the room the feeling of a small sheltered garden rather than a collection of movable containers.
The workshop side holds a potting recess behind a timber screen. The screen is made of narrow vertical slats with open spaces between them, allowing the recess to remain visually connected to the room. A stone shelf spans the back wall. Beneath it, shallow compartments accommodate empty pots, folded sacks, and a coiled length of hose. The shelf has a rounded front edge and a slightly recessed surface near the wall. Its worn finish differs from the smoother paving of the central path, making the working corner distinct without an additional doorway.
The bench beneath the far gable is built into a masonry recess. Its seat is timber, supported by brackets fixed beneath the front edge. The recess has a curved plaster ceiling that catches reflected light from the roof. A plain woven cushion covers the middle of the seat, and a narrow ledge runs along the wall behind it. The bench faces the entrance through the foliage. From that position, the path remains visible, while the planting beds soften the view of the surrounding brickwork. The recess provides a resting place without requiring movable furniture in the central passage.
A shallow basin is set against the wall near the potting recess. Its stone rim projects over a tiled backing, and the faucet has a simple cross handle. The tiles have an irregular glaze that appears smoother near their edges. A drain opening lies beneath a small removable strainer. The basin is supported by a masonry pedestal, leaving no exposed cabinet below it. The adjacent wall has a broad plaster patch around the plumbing connection. The patch remains visible as part of the room's accumulated repairs rather than being disguised by a decorative panel.
The residence wall contains an interior window overlooking the conservatory. Its deep reveal has a gently sloping sill, with plaster carried continuously around the corners. The frame is narrower than the entrance frame, and its glass is clear rather than textured. Inside the reveal, a slim curtain is gathered against the masonry. The window gives the neighboring room a view of the foliage and roof supports. Around it, the wall surface retains the small undulations of hand-applied plaster, contrasting with the more regular joints of the brickwork near the courtyard entrance.
Question
what would other income have increased to in 2009 absent the pre-tax gain from a land sale , in millions?
Answer choices
- A. 79
- B. 311
- C. 7900
- D. 195
Reference answer: A.
Exact evaluated input as JSON
{
"state": "{\"pre_text\": [\"an adverse development with respect to one claim in 2008 and favorable developments in three cases in 2009 .\", \"other costs were also lower in 2009 compared to 2008 , driven by a decrease in expenses for freight and property damages , employee travel , and utilities .\", \"in addition , higher bad debt expense in 2008 due to the uncertain impact of the recessionary economy drove a favorable year-over-year comparison .\", \"conversely , an additional expense of $ 30 million related to a transaction with pacer international , inc .\", \"and higher property taxes partially offset lower costs in 2009 .\", \"other costs were higher in 2008 compared to 2007 due to an increase in bad debts , state and local taxes , loss and damage expenses , utility costs , and other miscellaneous expenses totaling $ 122 million .\", \"conversely , personal injury costs ( including asbestos-related claims ) were $ 8 million lower in 2008 compared to 2007 .\", \"the reduction reflects improvements in our safety experience and lower estimated costs to resolve claims as indicated in the actuarial studies of our personal injury expense and annual reviews of asbestos-related claims in both 2008 and 2007 .\", \"the year-over-year comparison also includes the negative impact of adverse development associated with one claim in 2008 .\", \"in addition , environmental and toxic tort expenses were $ 7 million lower in 2008 compared to 2007 .\", \"non-operating items millions of dollars 2009 2008 2007 % ( % ) change 2009 v 2008 % ( % ) change 2008 v 2007 .\"], \"table\": [[\"millions of dollars\", \"2009\", \"2008\", \"2007\", \"% ( % ) change 2009 v 2008\", \"% ( % ) change 2008 v 2007\"], [\"other income\", \"$ 195\", \"$ 92\", \"$ 116\", \"112 % ( % )\", \"( 21 ) % ( % )\"], [\"interest expense\", \"-600 ( 600 )\", \"-511 ( 511 )\", \"-482 ( 482 )\", \"17\", \"6\"], [\"income taxes\", \"-1089 ( 1089 )\", \"-1318 ( 1318 )\", \"-1154 ( 1154 )\", \"-17 ( 17 )\", \"14\"]], \"post_text\": [\"other income 2013 other income increased $ 103 million in 2009 compared to 2008 primarily due to higher gains from real estate sales , which included the $ 116 million pre-tax gain from a land sale to the regional transportation district ( rtd ) in colorado and lower interest expense on our sale of receivables program , resulting from lower interest rates and a lower outstanding balance .\", \"reduced rental and licensing income and lower returns on cash investments , reflecting lower interest rates , partially offset these increases .\", \"other income decreased in 2008 compared to 2007 due to lower gains from real estate sales and decreased returns on cash investments reflecting lower interest rates .\", \"higher rental and licensing income and lower interest expense on our sale of receivables program partially offset the decreases .\", \"interest expense 2013 interest expense increased in 2009 versus 2008 due primarily to higher weighted- average debt levels .\", \"in 2009 , the weighted-average debt level was $ 9.6 billion ( including the restructuring of locomotive leases in may of 2009 ) , compared to $ 8.3 billion in 2008 .\", \"our effective interest rate was 6.3% ( 6.3 % ) in 2009 , compared to 6.1% ( 6.1 % ) in 2008 .\", \"interest expense increased in 2008 versus 2007 due to a higher weighted-average debt level of $ 8.3 billion , compared to $ 7.3 billion in 2007 .\", \"a lower effective interest rate of 6.1% ( 6.1 % ) in 2008 , compared to 6.6% ( 6.6 % ) in 2007 , partially offset the effects of the higher weighted-average debt level .\", \"income taxes 2013 income taxes were lower in 2009 compared to 2008 , driven by lower pre-tax income .\", \"our effective tax rate for the year was 36.5% ( 36.5 % ) compared to 36.1% ( 36.1 % ) in 2008 .\", \"income taxes were higher in 2008 compared to 2007 , driven by higher pre-tax income .\", \"our effective tax rates were 36.1% ( 36.1 % ) and 38.4% ( 38.4 % ) in 2008 and 2007 , respectively .\", \"the lower effective tax rate in 2008 resulted from several reductions in tax expense related to federal audits and state tax law changes .\", \"in addition , the effective tax rate in 2007 was increased by illinois legislation that increased deferred tax expense in the third quarter of 2007. .\"]}\n\nThe conservatory occupies a shallow courtyard between a brick residence and a former workshop. Its glazed roof rests on slender iron ribs, while the lower walls retain the texture of old lime plaster. The entrance faces a sheltered gravel court. Through the door, a broad stone path leads toward a recessed bench beneath the far gable. Planting beds lie beside the path, separated from it by low terracotta edging. The interior feels enclosed without feeling cramped: the roof exposes the sky, and the neighboring walls give the planting a sheltered boundary.\n\nThe entrance door has a heavy timber frame and a narrow pane of textured glass. Its handle is polished where hands naturally rest, but the surrounding metal retains a subdued finish. A deep threshold separates the gravel court from the interior paving. Beside the door, a shallow alcove accommodates a brush, a folded cloth, and a rack of garden footwear. The alcove is part of the wall rather than a freestanding cupboard, leaving the entrance passage clear. A slight projection above the doorway shelters the outer face of the timber from direct rain.\n\nThe main path consists of broad limestone slabs with softened edges. Their surface has a faint granular texture, and the joints contain a compact lime mortar. Near the planting beds, the paving has a narrow drainage channel with a removable grating. The channel follows the wall instead of crossing the entrance. The bed edging rises only slightly above the path, making the soil visible from the bench. Along the workshop wall, the slabs meet an older strip of brick paving whose uneven surface gives that side of the room a more domestic character.\n\nThe roof glazing is held in timber glazing bars laid over the iron frame. At the ridge, small ventilation panels sit beneath projecting caps. The caps shelter the opening edges while leaving a passage for air. The roof has a steeper pitch above the central path and a lower profile where it meets the neighboring walls. Narrow gutters follow the eaves. Their supporting brackets are visible from inside, where they form a quiet rhythm against the uninterrupted glass. The metalwork has a muted finish rather than a reflective coating.\n\nThe planting beside the residence wall is dominated by broad leaves and arching stems. Ferns occupy the shaded ground beneath taller foliage, and moss softens the exposed soil around the bed edges. The leaves differ in texture: some are smooth and leathery, others finely divided, with delicate veins visible against the roof light. None of the beds is raised on a stand. The plants emerge directly from a continuous soil surface, which gives the room the feeling of a small sheltered garden rather than a collection of movable containers.\n\nThe workshop side holds a potting recess behind a timber screen. The screen is made of narrow vertical slats with open spaces between them, allowing the recess to remain visually connected to the room. A stone shelf spans the back wall. Beneath it, shallow compartments accommodate empty pots, folded sacks, and a coiled length of hose. The shelf has a rounded front edge and a slightly recessed surface near the wall. Its worn finish differs from the smoother paving of the central path, making the working corner distinct without an additional doorway.\n\nThe bench beneath the far gable is built into a masonry recess. Its seat is timber, supported by brackets fixed beneath the front edge. The recess has a curved plaster ceiling that catches reflected light from the roof. A plain woven cushion covers the middle of the seat, and a narrow ledge runs along the wall behind it. The bench faces the entrance through the foliage. From that position, the path remains visible, while the planting beds soften the view of the surrounding brickwork. The recess provides a resting place without requiring movable furniture in the central passage.\n\nA shallow basin is set against the wall near the potting recess. Its stone rim projects over a tiled backing, and the faucet has a simple cross handle. The tiles have an irregular glaze that appears smoother near their edges. A drain opening lies beneath a small removable strainer. The basin is supported by a masonry pedestal, leaving no exposed cabinet below it. The adjacent wall has a broad plaster patch around the plumbing connection. The patch remains visible as part of the room's accumulated repairs rather than being disguised by a decorative panel.\n\nThe residence wall contains an interior window overlooking the conservatory. Its deep reveal has a gently sloping sill, with plaster carried continuously around the corners. The frame is narrower than the entrance frame, and its glass is clear rather than textured. Inside the reveal, a slim curtain is gathered against the masonry. The window gives the neighboring room a view of the foliage and roof supports. Around it, the wall surface retains the small undulations of hand-applied plaster, contrasting with the more regular joints of the brickwork near the courtyard entrance.",
"question": "what would other income have increased to in 2009 absent the pre-tax gain from a land sale , in millions?",
"choices": {
"A": "79",
"B": "311",
"C": "7900",
"D": "195"
}
}
Recorded model answers
The original column uses the control response paired with this variant. Missing responses and inputs outside a model’s limit remain visible.
| Model | Original answer | Variant answer | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| GLiDE v1.2 | A — 79 |
A — 79 |
Same answer |
| Decider v1.1 | A — 79 |
A — 79 |
Same answer |
| Jev | A — 79 |
A — 79 |
Same answer |
| Microsoft Decision-1 | A — 79 |
A — 79 |
Same answer |
| Clef | A — 79 |
A — 79 |
Same answer |
| Luna Decisions | A — 79 |
A — 79 |
Same answer |
| Clef Flash | B — 311 |
B — 311 |
Same answer |
| Strands Decider | A — 79 |
A — 79 |
Same answer |
| GLiNER2.5 Decide | A — 79 |
A — 79 |
Same answer |
| Laya | C — 7900 |
C — 7900 |
Same answer |
| CalDec v1 | B — 311 |
B — 311 |
Same answer |
Identifiers and recorded conditions
Variant ID: finqa/38769e073a06eace5ff9/text_length/2048/clean-source_first_financial_natural_lengths_full_0117
Input fingerprint: cf0551e720f1acb09ee760bdb53fe60ee5ac98915b1541871ac25f65d120fcb4
| Change | Recorded version |
|---|---|
| Text length | 2,048-token input target |
Source attribution and dataset terms are linked from the original question.