RaindropA practical guide to choosing decision modelsGitHub ↗

Evidence order · Present the evidence in a shuffled order variant

Original question · Other versions of this question · All variants

This version keeps the original reference answer. Its context, question instructions or answer choices were changed as described below.

Changed fields: context.

How the edits were constructed

Context

Read the full context

«Assistant: Do you have any other specifications?» «Assistant: Sorry there are no 4 star hotel fitting that description. Anything else?» «Assistant: What type of alternatives would you like to know about?» «Assistant: There are seven guesthouses in the North that offer parking and internet, I am not sure if the parking and internet are free though.» «Assistant: Parking is free on all 7, do you have a preference?» «Assistant: I have selected the kirkwood house, it is moderately priced and the postal code is cb41da, can I help with anything else?» Before the Assistant asks about other specifications, «User: I am looking for a place to stay in Cambridge. I prefer it to be in the north and include free wifi, please. » After the Assistant asks about other specifications and before the Assistant replies to the four-star parking specification, «User: Yes, if you could find a 4 star hotel with free parking that would be great.» After the Assistant replies to the four-star parking specification and before the Assistant asks what type of alternatives are wanted, «User: Can you list alternatives close to 4 star with free parking?» After the Assistant asks what type of alternatives are wanted and before the Assistant replies to the north-and-wifi specification, «User: I need some place in the north, four stars and having free wifi. » After the Assistant replies to the north-and-wifi specification and before the Assistant asks for a preference, «User: I really need one that has free parking. Can you check again please? » After the Assistant asks for a preference and before the Assistant replies to the request to choose a place and provide its postcode and price range, «User: No preference really. Could you pick one and get me the postcode and price range please?» After the Assistant replies to the request to choose a place and provide its postcode and price range, «User: I also need a train going to kings lynn on Wednesday. »

Question

What emotion does the final user message express, taking the conversation into account?

Answer choices

  • 4. Abusive
  • 1. Fearful
  • 0. Neutral
  • 5. Excited
  • 3. Apologetic
  • 6. Satisfied
  • 2. Dissatisfied

Reference answer: 0.

Exact evaluated input as JSON
{
  "state": "«Assistant: Do you have any other specifications?»\n«Assistant: Sorry there are no 4 star hotel fitting that description. Anything else?»\n«Assistant: What type of alternatives would you like to know about?»\n«Assistant: There are seven guesthouses in the North that offer parking and internet, I am not sure if the parking and internet are free though.»\n«Assistant: Parking is free on all 7, do you have a preference?»\n«Assistant: I have selected the kirkwood house, it is moderately priced and the postal code is cb41da, can I help with anything else?»\nBefore the Assistant asks about other specifications,\n«User: I am looking for a place to stay in Cambridge. I prefer it to be in the north and include free wifi, please. »\nAfter the Assistant asks about other specifications and before the Assistant replies to the four-star parking specification,\n«User: Yes, if you could find a 4 star hotel with free parking that would be great.»\nAfter the Assistant replies to the four-star parking specification and before the Assistant asks what type of alternatives are wanted,\n«User: Can you list alternatives close to 4 star with free parking?»\nAfter the Assistant asks what type of alternatives are wanted and before the Assistant replies to the north-and-wifi specification,\n«User: I need some place in the north, four stars and having free wifi. »\nAfter the Assistant replies to the north-and-wifi specification and before the Assistant asks for a preference,\n«User: I really need one that has free parking. Can you check again please? »\nAfter the Assistant asks for a preference and before the Assistant replies to the request to choose a place and provide its postcode and price range,\n«User: No preference really. Could you pick one and get me the postcode and price range please?»\nAfter the Assistant replies to the request to choose a place and provide its postcode and price range,\n«User: I also need a train going to kings lynn on Wednesday. »",
  "question": "What emotion does the final user message express, taking the conversation into account?",
  "choices": {
    "4": "Abusive",
    "1": "Fearful",
    "0": "Neutral",
    "5": "Excited",
    "3": "Apologetic",
    "6": "Satisfied",
    "2": "Dissatisfied"
  }
}

Recorded model answers

The original column uses the control response paired with this variant. Missing responses and inputs outside a model’s limit remain visible.

Model Original answer Variant answer Change
GLiDE v1.2 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
Decider v1.1 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
Jev 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
Microsoft Decision-1 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
Clef 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
Luna Decisions 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
Clef Flash 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
Strands Decider 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
GLiNER2.5 Decide 0 — Neutral 0 — Neutral Same answer
Laya 6 — Satisfied 3 — Apologetic Different answer
CalDec v1 6 — Satisfied 6 — Satisfied Same answer

Ordering comparison: coupled wording reference chronology or representation. Only the exact matched comparison sets contribute to the reported ordering contrasts.

Identifiers and recorded conditions

Variant ID: emowoz/06193d0704f3c42c9e82/presentation_order/shuffled_presentation/clean-source_first_emowoz_temporal_shuffle_full_0349

Input fingerprint: 5a2e996f10d1930a87b11f37ea00a40f36209a92e29b47b2798ade25e879ae3c

Change Recorded version
Evidence order Present the evidence in a shuffled order

Source attribution and dataset terms are linked from the original question.

Type to search questions, variants and documentation.