RaindropA practical guide to choosing decision modelsGitHub ↗

Causal reasoning · question 52

Back to Causal reasoning · All capabilities

Question ID: cladder/f4cfa4020dfb290029e1
Source: CLadder
Input format: native choices

Explore this question’s altered versions

Context

Imagine a self-contained, hypothetical world with only the following conditions, and without any unmentioned factors or causal relationships: The captain has a direct effect on the private and the corporal. The corporal has a direct effect on prisoner. The private has a direct effect on prisoner. For captains who release prisoners, the probability of the prisoner's death is 33%. For captains who execute prisoners, the probability of the prisoner's death is 81%.

Question

For captains who execute prisoners, would it be less likely to see the prisoner's death if the captain had ordered the release of the prisoner?

Answer choices

  • yes: Yes
  • no: No

Reference answer: Yes (yes)

Exact evaluated input as JSON
{
  "state": "Imagine a self-contained, hypothetical world with only the following conditions, and without any unmentioned factors or causal relationships: The captain has a direct effect on the private and the corporal. The corporal has a direct effect on prisoner. The private has a direct effect on prisoner.\nFor captains who release prisoners, the probability of the prisoner's death is 33%. For captains who execute prisoners, the probability of the prisoner's death is 81%.",
  "question": "For captains who execute prisoners, would it be less likely to see the prisoner's death if the captain had ordered the release of the prisoner?",
  "choices": {
    "yes": "Yes",
    "no": "No"
  }
}

Recorded model answers

Model Answer Outcome
Astra Yes Correct
Opus 5.5 Yes Correct
GLiDE v1.2 Yes Correct
Decider v1.1 Yes Correct
Jev Yes Correct
Microsoft Decision-1 Yes Correct
Clef Yes Correct
Luna Decisions Yes Correct
Clef Flash Yes Correct
Strands Decider No Incorrect
GLiNER2.5 Decide Yes Correct
Laya No Incorrect
CalDec v1 No Incorrect

Source and sharing

Attribution: CLadder original creators; see source.
Terms: MIT. Source sharing decision.
The capability assignment and choice-format normalization are part of this experiment. Source data retain their own terms.

Exact source locator and input fingerprint
{
  "source_locator": {
    "path": "data/cladder-v1-questions.json",
    "record": "649",
    "kind": "source_file_record"
  },
  "source_revision": "3d2d1169b4b939a09048a6a75956c8972a93cc38",
  "input_hash": "662cbdc120b3e41ada063da054b8266c02d2171b4695e99d34458d2380abaa7f"
}

Type to search questions, variants and documentation.